Realistic Wrote: I'm going to tell you this honestly. I'm a experienced web dev and I run my own webdev/IT business. I have designers who are experienced and also make themes like these.
But your theme looks so bad. The colors are just YUCK. It really looks like a free theme. The font shadows look also shit. Imo it looks a shit rip of Nulled. You must really learn more before you start selling these kind of themes. I'd say start working of a template and edit that youself because I wouldn't really pay for that.
I'm sorry but this is my honest opinion.
If you want I can write a detailed review of each and every step what I like and don't.
3/10.
He said he was told to replicate a drawn design(?) and actually code it, so he didn't design it himself and made it how they wanted it. That doesn't make him a bad, not designer.. but coder I guess?