You can wait for MyBB 2.0 release and then it'll be Kuch easier to decide which one is best. The new release has been much hyped in regard of never before seen features.
At present, Xenforo leads in my eyes.
MyBB
Xenforo VS Mybb
Submitted by GXD3S, 24-08-2017, 03:37 AM, Thread ID: 45014
Thread Closed
Xenforo or MyBB?
MyBB
Votes:
31
% of votes:
75.61%
Xenforo
Votes:
10
% of votes:
24.39%
You have already voted. Click on the dropdown to undo your vote.