Review a member

Hey, I just had this idea, it might be wrong, but let's have a section where people can post requests to review other members, like I'm having a deal with someone I don't know, I can post there, and you guys can advise to deal with him or not, by votes or such.

I think it's a great idea to be implemented, what do you think?

Good idea though there's already a feature similar to what you're referring to. We already have a vouch system where you can check if the user has positive/negative vouches with comments included regarding how the deal went. You can check it on the user's profile: https://nulledbb.com/vouch.php?uid=2579

I think what NBB needs to do is make the vouch system more noticeable so that it will be utilized more often to help when about to deal with other members of the forum.

So a section where friends vouch for friends.

22-02-2016, 09:32 AM

Aoki Wrote: So a section where friends vouch for friends.

Well the user requesting the review is free to take it or leave it, the review of particular members I mean.
It will not be: "Review me :hurr:"

It will be: "X Review" people will post: "I tried dealing with him, he's childish" or "He's great, he's my dad actually" :noh:

So it'll be alright I think

It will increase chances of scamming. We have Vouch system to check the review of user.

22-02-2016, 12:04 PM

Devil Wrote: It will increase chances of scamming. We have Vouch system to check the review of user.

How does that prevent scamming?

22-02-2016, 12:05 PM

Python Wrote:

22-02-2016, 12:04 PM

Devil Wrote: It will increase chances of scamming. We have Vouch system to check the review of user.

How does that prevent scamming?

I'm having a deal with someone I don't know, I can post there, and you guys can advise to deal with him or not, by votes or such.

Okay let me explain you. Someone like you person x reviews someone else person y. Let's assume that person x posted review about Y saying that i have done many deals with this person and he is legit buyer. Everytime i paid him in advance and he does the work perfectly. Now let's assume person x is well reputed on this forum and does review/fake review and if someone goes first to pay for person Y's service or anything. and person Y get the money first and scam that person.

This is similar to the vouching system though.

Vouch system and reputation system could be used for this i guess.

22-02-2016, 12:12 PM

Devil Wrote:

22-02-2016, 12:05 PM

Python Wrote:

22-02-2016, 12:04 PM

Devil Wrote: It will increase chances of scamming. We have Vouch system to check the review of user.

How does that prevent scamming?

I'm having a deal with someone I don't know, I can post there, and you guys can advise to deal with him or not, by votes or such.

Okay let me explain you. Someone like you person x reviews someone else person y. Let's assume that person x posted review about Y saying that i have done many deals with this person and he is legit buyer. Everytime i paid him in advance and he does the work perfectly. Now let's assume person x is well reputed on this forum and does review/fake review and if someone goes first to pay for person Y's service or anything. and person Y get the money first and scam that person.

Well if that's the case, we can't trust anyone, can we? :hurr:

---

True, thanks for sharing, if anyone has anything else to add, feel free, else you can close this